A CleanMyMac alternative for Mac Power Cleaner Studio vs CleanMyMac
Looking for a CleanMyMac alternative? Power Cleaner Studio is a native, sandboxed Mac cleaner from the Mac App Store: junk cleanup, a duplicate and look-alike photo finder, an app uninstaller with leftovers, Disk Map and System Monitor. Every cleanup can be undone, it needs no Full Disk Access, and it costs $9 once after a free 14-day trial.
About CleanMyMac: MacPaw's all-in-one Mac cleaner, optimizer and malware remover ('A Mac saver'), sold as Essential Trio and All-in-One plans (monthly, yearly or one-time) on the MacPaw Store, inside the Setapp subscription, and as a feature-reduced Mac App Store edition with its own plans. The current version is 5.x; MacPaw dropped the 'X' in 2024 and says it has '25+ tools'.
CleanMyMac's pricing and features checked on from cleanmymac.com, macpaw.com, apps.apple.com. Prices change; check their site before buying.
Power Cleaner Studio
macOS 14+ · native · sandboxed
$9 one-time
14-day free Pro trial · no subscription · Family Sharing · refundable via Apple
Free to scan and clean junk. Pro cleanup tools free for 14 days, then $9 once.
CleanMyMac
Mac cleaner
$39.95/yr All-in-One
$39.95/yr All-in-One or $19.95/yr Essential Trio (1 Mac), or $119.95 one-time (All-in-One, major upgrades cost extra)
As listed on cleanmymac.com
MacPaw's all-in-one Mac cleaner, optimizer and malware remover ('A Mac saver'), sold as Essential Trio and All-in-One plans (monthly, yearly or one-time) on the MacPaw Store, inside the Setapp subscription, and as a feature-reduced Mac App Store edition with its own plans.
Where we win
- ✓$9 once for Pro, compared with $39.95 a year for All-in-One or $119.95 one-time (which charges again for major upgrades)
- ✓A free tier with no time limit (scan, Smart Scan junk cleanup, Disk Map, large/old files, duplicate and look-alike finding, System Monitor), plus a 14-day Pro trial with no automatic charge, compared with CleanMyMac's 7-day trial
- ✓Works without Full Disk Access. MacPaw's own support article says CleanMyMac needs Full Disk Access to clean, maintain and protect the Mac.
- ✓Zero telemetry and no account. CleanMyMac's App Store privacy label lists device ID and usage data collected for analytics.
- ✓Every cleanup goes to the Trash or the app's Quarantine first, with Undo, and a path policy refuses critical paths. The System Monitor shows the real macOS memory pressure and swap and never quits apps.
Where CleanMyMac wins (honest)
- ◐Broad toolkit in one app: malware removal (Moonlock Engine with Quick, Balanced and Deep scans), Smart Care one-click scan, background and login-item management, and app update tracking
- ◐Cloud Cleanup shows what is filling iCloud Drive, Dropbox, Google Drive and OneDrive, which PCS does not analyze
- ◐Space Lens storage map, a menu-bar app with CPU and memory monitors, and 24/7 technical and sales support
- ◐Long track record (MacPaw lists 18 years, 2008–2026), notarized by Apple, 30-day money-back guarantee, and plans covering 1, 2 or 5 Macs
- ◐Optional $119.95 one-time license for people who don't want a subscription
Feature-by-feature
Same features across both columns, no asterisks. ✓ = full, ◐ = partial, ✕ = no.
| Feature | | CleanMyMac |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | ||
| One-time purchase (not subscription) | ✓ | ◐ |
| Free tier (forever, not just trial) | ✓ | ✕ |
| Refund window | — Via Apple | — 30-day |
| Trust & privacy | ||
| Zero telemetry / analytics | ✓ | ✕ |
| Sandboxed (Mac App Store distribution) | ✓ | ◐ |
| Works without Full Disk Access | ✓ | ◐ partial (runs without FDA but, per MacPaw, 'cannot scan all areas') |
| Open-source components | ✕ | ✕ |
| Cleanup | ||
| Junk / cache cleanup | ✓ | ✓ |
| Duplicate finder (SHA-256) | ✓ | ✓ |
| Similar photos (on-device image analysis) | ✓ | ✓ |
| App uninstaller + leftover discovery | ✓ | ✓ |
| Curated rules for difficult apps (Adobe etc.) | ✓ yes (15 apps) | — unknown |
| Xcode / Brew / Trash quick-cleanup recipes | ✓ yes (Xcode / Brew / Trash) | ◐ |
| Monitoring | ||
| Live system CPU + RAM + per-process | ✓ | ◐ |
| Menu-bar HUD with sparklines | ✓ | ✓ |
| Honest memory-pressure indicator | ✓ | ✓ yes (shows pressure + swap; also offers a one-click 'free up' RAM action) |
| Disk usage treemap (DaisyDisk-style) | ✓ yes (sunburst + treemap) | ✓ yes (Space Lens) |
| Safety | ||
| Cleanup goes to Trash or Quarantine first, with Undo | ✓ | ✕ no (MacPaw docs: duplicates and downloads are 'deleted permanently, bypassing the Trash'; only Photos items go to Recently Deleted) |
| Refuses critical paths (/System, ~/.ssh, …) | ✓ yes (DestructivePathPolicy) | ◐ |
| Review-before-delete sheet | ✓ | ✓ |
| Extras | ||
| MCP server for AI agents (Claude / ChatGPT) | ✓ | ✕ |
| Antivirus / malware scan | ✕ | ✓ |
| Bundled VPN | ✕ | ✕ |
| Ad-blocker | ✕ | ✕ |
| Command-line tool | ✓ yes (pcs-mcp) | ✕ |
What CleanMyMac does that inspires our roadmap
We watch every alternative. Here's where CleanMyMac pushed our thinking:
- →A one-tap 'Smart Care'-style run that chains Smart Scan, large/old files and duplicates into a single review sheet
- →Cloud-folder size breakdown (iCloud Drive / Dropbox / Google Drive local folders) inside Disk Map, kept on-device
- →An 'app update tracker' style list next to the App Uninstaller (read-only, no auto-updating)
See the changelog for what's shipping next.
CleanMyMac alternative: questions
Is there a free CleanMyMac alternative for Mac?
CleanMyMac has only a 7-day free trial. Power Cleaner Studio is a free Mac App Store download. Its free tier includes junk cleanup with an item-by-item review, a Disk Map, large/old file and duplicate finding, and a System Monitor, with no time limit.
Is CleanMyMac a one-time purchase?
Mostly not. MacPaw sells it as a subscription ($19.95/yr Essential Trio or $39.95/yr All-in-One for 1 Mac), with a $119.95 one-time option that doesn't include major upgrades. Power Cleaner Studio Pro is a one-time $9 in-app purchase with no subscription.
Does CleanMyMac need Full Disk Access?
Yes. MacPaw's support documentation says CleanMyMac needs Full Disk Access to clean, maintain and protect your Mac, and can't scan all areas without it. Power Cleaner Studio is sandboxed and works without Full Disk Access.
How does Power Cleaner Studio's price compare to CleanMyMac?
Power Cleaner Studio is free to download, with a 14-day free trial of Pro and then a one-time $9 purchase, no subscription. CleanMyMac: $39.95/yr All-in-One or $19.95/yr Essential Trio (1 Mac), or $119.95 one-time (All-in-One, major upgrades cost extra).
Why pick Power Cleaner Studio over CleanMyMac?
$9 once for Pro, compared with $39.95 a year for All-in-One or $119.95 one-time (which charges again for major upgrades). A free tier with no time limit (scan, Smart Scan junk cleanup, Disk Map, large/old files, duplicate and look-alike finding, System Monitor), plus a 14-day Pro trial with no automatic charge, compared with CleanMyMac's 7-day trial. Works without Full Disk Access. MacPaw's own support article says CleanMyMac needs Full Disk Access to clean, maintain and protect the Mac..
What is CleanMyMac better at?
Broad toolkit in one app: malware removal (Moonlock Engine with Quick, Balanced and Deep scans), Smart Care one-click scan, background and login-item management, and app update tracking. Cloud Cleanup shows what is filling iCloud Drive, Dropbox, Google Drive and OneDrive, which PCS does not analyze. Space Lens storage map, a menu-bar app with CPU and memory monitors, and 24/7 technical and sales support.
Try the CleanMyMac alternative free
Free download: scan, junk cleanup, Disk Map and System Monitor. Try every Pro feature free for 14 days, then $9 once.
Looking for another comparison? vs MacKeeper · vs CCleaner for Mac · vs BuhoCleaner · vs Cleaner One Pro · vs Mole · vs DaisyDisk · vs AppCleaner · vs Pearcleaner · vs Gemini 2